Your neighbor has been using hedge trimmers and leaf bags to turn their gardens into barren clean lots. Their gardens look much cleaner and manicured. The wild and untidy looks better in contrast, with brown with bobbing coneflower heads in the breeze and morning glory vines hanging over their fences.
Bring Hummingbirds Right To Your Window!
Check PriceYour neighbor may not realize this but they’ve just evicted around 200 different species from their backyard.
Save this article for later so you don't lose it. Enter your email and I'll send it to you now—plus you'll get my favorite backyard birding tips delivered to your inbox.
You've been running a wildlife sanctuary, while they snap pictures of their autumnal Instagram perfection. Those 'messy' seed heads are feeding goldfinches and sparrows, while the hollow stems provide housing for beneficial insects to come out next spring to help pollinate your veggies. Even those dying vines are providing late-season nectar for monarchs that are starting their migration down to Mexico.
The magic shows because nature doesn't follow our calendars. The fall season on your calendar doesn't mean that the plants and animals are ready to shut down for winter.
The September wildlife rush hour
From a wildlife perspective, September is like Black Friday at the mall. Migrating birds need high-energy seeds to fuel their journeys that will take them thousands of miles. Late-emerging butterflies need to cool down to find sources of nectar. Insects that are on the ground need to find safe spots to hide for the winter.
When you close for the summer, you are shutting down for the dinner rush. Native and other wild bees need food sources that won’t be available until blooms of asters and goldenrods (beg. Sept). Ruby-throated hummingbirds migrate in sync with the honeysuckle and cardinal flower nectar and therefore miss the food source to migrate. When you remove these late season food sources, you make wildlife go further and work harder to get the resources they need.
According to the University of Delaware, gardens that remain uncut until after the first hard frost promote 50% more overwintering beneficial insects than those that are cut back in early fall.
Reading Nature's Real Signals
The 'best practices' of garden management boils down to one primary factor: learning to appreciate the cues that nature is providing as opposed to simply looking at your calendar. Below are the accurate indicators that determine when the inhabitants of the garden, no longer require the sanctuary that your garden has provided:
First hard frost (not first cool night): This usually occurs 2-4 weeks after the official first day of fall. Many plants will keep producing nectar and seeds until temperatures drop below 28°F for a minimum of 4 hours.
Get our free Hummingbird Attraction Guide! Plus, we'll send you our best tips for attracting more birds to your yard.
Seed head depletion happens when birds eat a lot of the seeds of the coneflowers, sunflowers, and native grasses. It may be a sign that the dinner rush is ending.
Completion of monarch migration: By mid-October, most areas see the completion of southern migrations of the Monarch butterflies. If there have been no sightings of Monarchs in the past two weeks, it is time to consider that late season nectar sources are of less significance.
The Strategy of Selective Cutting
You don’t have to choose between a garden that is messy and difficult to maintain and a wildlife sanctuary. Experienced gardeners can use selective cutting to keep the ecosystem looking intentional.
For ornamental grasses, cut to 12 inches instead of the ground level. This keeps the crown structure that insects use for winter shelter, while removing the messy brown tops.
Please leave all native wildflower plants and seed-producing plants until spring. This includes coneflowers, black-eyed susans, joe-pye weeds, and native asters.
Define the edges by trimming the plants that can be seen from your primary viewing areas. Leave the back borders wild – most wildlife activity occurs in these zones that are less disturbed.
Making Messy Look Intentional
The secret to achieving the 'productive mess' look is having clear divisions between the tidied areas and the natural areas. Having a simple border with stones or fencing, or even just a mowed strip can show that your wild areas are intentional choices rather than an area that has been neglected.
Position your tallest seed heads at the back, and place the smaller ones in front. This gives them a more thought out look than just a random scattering.
Consider placing a simple sign or small decorative item near your wild areas. Signs like \\"Pollinator habitat – Please don't disturb\\" or just a decorative garden stake indicate your intentions to neighbors and visitors.
What Happens When You Wait
Gardens that are left as is in fall and winter will turn into busy ecosystems that actually do a lot of good for the garden in the following year. More good bugs will be around to help reduce the number of pest issues. With more food for them, birds will be in that area for the winter and really establish a feeding environment. The soil will become more healthy and more decomposed plant material will be added because nobody will be removing it.
You'll also learn about all the winter interest you never knew about before! Ornamental grasses even catch snow beautifully. Seed heads create amazing structures against the winter sky. Winter ice storms transform dead flower stalks into crystal sculptures!
The wonderful part is all this magic is happening while you sit inside enjoying your hot coffee rather than working in the yard. The ecosystem is literally managing your garden for you. It's creating beauty and supporting wildlife while you sit back and relax.
Trust the process! Let your garden teach you patience and the true beauty of autumn. Nature's timing is wiser than any calendar. Resist the urge to clean up early.
