There’s something magnetic about cardinals. Maybe it’s that brilliant flash of red against winter snow, or the cheerful song they bring to summer mornings. Whatever it is, these birds are backyard favorites—and they’re worth the effort to attract. The good news? Getting them to visit isn’t complicated, but it does require understanding what they actually want.
Why Cardinals Matter (and Why They’re So Picky)
Save this article for later so you don't lose it. Enter your email and I'll send it to you now—plus you'll get my favorite backyard birding tips delivered to your inbox.
Birdfy Solar Powered Bird House with Camera
Check PriceCardinals are iconic backyard visitors that many people specifically want to attract, and understanding what they actually prefer is the first step to success. Unlike some birds that’ll eat just about anything you toss out, cardinals have clear favorites. They’re ground foragers by nature, which means they prefer platform feeders or hoppers where they can perch comfortably while cracking seeds with their thick, powerful bills.
These birds are also year-round residents across much of the eastern United States and parts of the Southwest, so once you attract a pair, they’ll likely stick around through all four seasons. That’s the beauty of cardinals—they’re not just seasonal visitors. They nest in your yard, raise their young nearby, and become part of your daily rhythm. But here’s the catch: if your feeder doesn’t offer what they want, they’ll simply move on to a neighbor’s yard that does.
Cardinals are selective, but they’re not unreasonable. They just need the right fuel—high-fat, high-protein seeds that give them the energy to survive harsh winters and raise multiple broods each year. Get the food right, and everything else falls into place.
The Foundation: Black Oil Sunflower Seeds
Black oil sunflower seeds are the proven gold standard for cardinals—packed with 40 percent oil content and thin hulls that cardinals crack effortlessly with their thick bills. This isn’t marketing fluff. According to research from bird feeding experts and organizations like the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, black oil sunflower consistently ranks as the most preferred seed among cardinals.
What makes black oil sunflower so effective? First, the shells are thinner than striped sunflower seeds, which means less work for the bird and quicker access to the nutritious kernel inside. Cardinals have strong beaks designed for seed-cracking, but they still appreciate efficiency. Second, the oil content is exceptionally high, delivering the calories and fat cardinals need to maintain their body temperature and energy levels year-round.
You’ll find black oil sunflower at nearly every feed store, garden center, and online retailer. It’s widely available in bulk, which keeps costs down if you’re feeding birds regularly. Buy it fresh—look for plump, dark seeds without a lot of dust or debris in the bag. Stale or old seeds lose nutritional value and can even develop mold, which birds will avoid.
If you’re just starting out and want to test the waters, black oil sunflower alone will absolutely work. Fill a hopper feeder or platform feeder with it, set it up in a visible spot near some cover, and wait. Cardinals will find it, often within days.
The Mix: Building Your Cardinal Blend
The real magic happens when you combine black oil sunflower with safflower seed, creating a mix that cardinals love while keeping less desirable fillers out of your feeder. Safflower is the secret weapon in a cardinal-focused blend. It’s a white, slightly bitter seed that cardinals adore—but squirrels, grackles, and starlings tend to avoid it.
This gives you a huge advantage. Instead of watching squirrels raid your feeder or aggressive birds dominate the perches, you’re creating a dining experience tailored specifically to cardinals, chickadees, titmice, and other songbirds. The bitter taste of safflower doesn’t bother cardinals at all, and they’ll crack through it just as easily as sunflower.
A basic cardinal blend looks like this: 70% black oil sunflower and 30% safflower. This ratio gives you the high-fat appeal of sunflower while adding the selective benefits of safflower. Some birders flip the ratio depending on their local wildlife pressure—if squirrels are relentless, increasing safflower to 50% can help.
You can also add a small percentage of shelled sunflower hearts (sometimes called sunflower chips) to the mix. These are more expensive, but they eliminate waste since there are no hulls to clean up. Cardinals will eat them readily, and they’re especially helpful in winter when every calorie counts.
The key is simplicity. You’re not trying to create a blend for every species. You’re zeroing in on what cardinals prefer most, and letting other species benefit as a bonus.
Making It at Home: Your Own Cardinal Cocktail
Get our free Hummingbird Attraction Guide! Plus, we'll send you our best tips for attracting more birds to your yard.
You can skip the store-bought bags and create a custom blend using simple ingredients you control, letting you adjust the ratio to what cardinals in your yard prefer most. Making your own mix isn’t just cost-effective—it’s also fresher, cleaner, and completely customizable.
Start by sourcing your ingredients in bulk. Many farm supply stores, wild bird specialty shops, and online retailers sell black oil sunflower and safflower by the 25- or 50-pound bag. Buying in bulk cuts your per-pound cost significantly, especially if you’re feeding year-round.
Here’s a simple recipe to get you started:
- 35 pounds black oil sunflower seeds
- 15 pounds safflower seeds
- Optional: 5 pounds shelled sunflower hearts
Mix everything in a large, clean container—a plastic storage bin with a lid works perfectly. Use a small scoop or bucket to blend the seeds thoroughly so each feeder refill has a consistent ratio. Store the mix in an airtight container in a cool, dry place. Garages, sheds, and basements are ideal, as long as they’re protected from moisture and pests.
This batch will last several weeks to a couple of months depending on how many feeders you’re filling and how many birds you’re hosting. The beauty of making your own blend is flexibility. If you notice cardinals favoring one seed over another, adjust the ratio next time. Some birders go heavier on safflower in spring and summer, then boost the sunflower content in fall and winter when birds need extra fat for warmth.
What NOT to Put in Your Mix
Skip the filler seeds like red milo, wheat, and colored millet—cardinals will toss them aside, and you’ll end up wasting money on seeds they simply won’t eat. Filler seeds are the downfall of most commercial blends. They’re cheap, they add weight to the bag, and they make the mix look abundant. But cardinals don’t want them.
Red milo is particularly problematic. It’s a common ingredient in low-cost wild bird mixes, but most songbirds, including cardinals, ignore it completely. You’ll see it pile up under your feeder as birds toss it to the ground while searching for the good stuff. The same goes for wheat, oats, and cracked corn in a cardinal-focused blend. These grains attract pigeons, house sparrows, and rodents—not the vibrant red birds you’re hoping for.
White proso millet is fine for ground-feeding sparrows and doves, but cardinals aren’t particularly interested. If your goal is specifically cardinals, leave it out. Colored millet (often dyed red or yellow) is pure marketing and offers no nutritional benefit.
Stick to the essentials: black oil sunflower, safflower, and optionally some sunflower hearts. That’s it. When you eliminate the junk, your feeder becomes more efficient, cleaner, and far more attractive to the birds you actually want to see.
Storage and Serving Tips
Making a fresh batch monthly and storing your surplus in airtight containers keeps your blend fresh, affordable, and ready to attract cardinals year-round. Seed freshness matters more than most people realize. Old, stale seeds lose their oil content, develop off flavors, and can harbor mold or bacteria. Cardinals have a keen sense of what’s fresh and what’s not—they’ll choose a neighbor’s feeder with quality seed over yours if the food isn’t up to standard.
Store your seed mix in airtight containers like heavy-duty plastic bins, galvanized steel trash cans, or food-grade buckets with locking lids. This protects the seeds from moisture, insects, and rodents. Keep containers in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight. Heat and humidity accelerate spoilage, so avoid storing seed in hot garages or damp basements.
When filling your feeders, only add what will be consumed within a week or two. In wet or humid climates, seed can spoil quickly. If you notice clumping, discoloration, or a musty smell, toss it out and refill with fresh mix. Clean your feeders regularly—at least once every two weeks—with a solution of one part vinegar to four parts water. Rinse thoroughly and let dry completely before refilling.
During peak feeding seasons (late fall through early spring), you might go through seed faster. That’s normal. Cardinals and other birds rely heavily on feeders when natural food sources are scarce. In summer, consumption may drop as birds forage for insects and berries. Adjust your batch size and refill frequency based on what you observe.
Beyond Seeds: What Else Cardinals Need
While the right seeds bring cardinals to your feeder, adding fresh water and nearby shrubs for shelter creates an irresistible complete habitat. Cardinals don’t live on seeds alone. They need water for drinking and bathing, especially in winter when natural sources freeze and in summer when heat stresses their systems.
A simple birdbath, refreshed daily, makes a huge difference. Cardinals prefer shallow water—about one to two inches deep—with a rough surface they can grip. In winter, consider a heated birdbath to keep water accessible when temperatures drop. You’ll see cardinals visit multiple times a day, and that regular presence strengthens their bond with your yard.
Cover is equally important. Cardinals are naturally cautious birds. They prefer feeders positioned near shrubs, small trees, or dense vegetation where they can retreat if a hawk appears or if they simply want a break between feeding bouts. Evergreens like juniper, holly, and arborvitae provide excellent year-round shelter. Deciduous shrubs like viburnum, dogwood, and serviceberry offer nesting sites and natural berries that cardinals enjoy.
If your yard is open and exposed, cardinals may be hesitant to visit even the best feeder. Adding a few native shrubs creates the layered habitat they instinctively seek. Plant them within 10 to 15 feet of your feeder for maximum effect. Over time, this combination of food, water, and shelter transforms your yard into a cardinal magnet.
Real Results in Your Backyard
Cardinals respond quickly to quality food, and once they discover your feeder, they often return regularly and bring family members along. You might see a single male cardinal first—bright red, unmistakable, cautiously checking things out. Within days, his mate will join him, her warm brown and red tones just as beautiful. By the next season, you could have juvenile cardinals visiting too, still showing traces of their darker juvenile plumage.
Cardinals are creatures of habit. Once they establish your yard as a reliable food source, they’ll incorporate it into their daily routine. You’ll start to notice them arriving at the same times—early morning just after sunrise, late afternoon before dusk. They’ll visit in pairs or small family groups, and their cheerful calls will become part of your yard’s soundtrack.
The consistency of offering a quality cardinal blend pays off in ways beyond just numbers. You’ll witness courtship feeding in spring, where the male offers seeds to the female as part of their bonding ritual. You’ll see fledglings learning to crack seeds on their own. You’ll enjoy the brilliant contrast of a male cardinal perched on snow-covered branches in January, sustained by the food you’ve provided.
This isn’t instant gratification—it’s relationship-building with the natural world. But if you stick with it, keep your feeders clean and filled, and create the habitat cardinals need, the results speak for themselves. A yard full of red isn’t just possible—it’s predictable.
So grab some black oil sunflower, mix in that safflower, and get your feeder ready. The cardinals are out there, and they’re looking for exactly what you’re about to offer. Happy birding!