Everything below is reproduced verbatim from F. E. L. Beal’s federal Bulletin 171, Food of the Robins and Bluebirds of the United States (1915), including the growers’ own accounts of shooting robins by the thousand — legal then, reproduced here as a historical record and not as advice.
Burpee Wildflower 25
See Today's PriceWhere the robins go
While such cases are not numerous or of very great importance in the East, it is quite otherwise in California, where the robin is a winter bird and is abundant at just the time when wild fruits are largely out of bearing, except such as retain their fruit over winter. In years when this customary food is scarce, robins appear in the valleys in immense numbers and eat olives so eagerly and persistently that the loss is often serious and occasionally disastrous.
Save this article for later so you don't lose it. Enter your email and I'll send it to you now—plus you'll get my favorite backyard birding tips delivered to your inbox.
Sometimes, indeed, it is only by the most untiring efforts with considerable outlay of labor and money that any part of the crop can be saved. Fortunately, such extensive damage is not done every year, although here and there the olive crop may suffer.
The invasion of 1900-1901
There is probably no more striking example of this exceptional and intermittent damage to fruit by birds than that which occurred in the winter of 1900-1901. In that year olive orchards in various parts of California were invaded by immense numbers of robins, which ate the fruit and in some instances destroyed the whole crop.
Even in orchards where persistent effort was made to kill them or drive them away they ruined from one-fourth to one-half of the yield. Olive orchards in Santa Clara Valley were especially afflicted. Paul Masson, who owned two orchards near Saratoga, as quoted by the San Jose Mercury of January 17, 1901, says:
In my largest orchard of about 500 trees adjoining a larger orchard of about 50 acres on the El Quito farm, which is owned by H. E. Goodrich, are thousands of robins, which are destroying all the fruit on the trees. About two months ago I estimated that my trees would yield about 4 tons of olives, but Sunday, when I visited my orchard, I found the fruit would not be worth picking.
I killed some of the robins, and upon examination found as many as five or six whole olives in the crop of each bird. Besides those which the bird had swallowed whole, many olives are pecked so that they are spoiled for market. Sunday there were not less than 50,000 robins on my place, and they are equally as plentiful on El Quito farm.
Sunday there were not less than 50,000 robins on my place, and they are equally as plentiful on El Quito farm.
The neighboring orchard
Edward E. Goodrich, owner of the El Quito farm and olive orchard, quoted by the same authority, states: The so-called robin is a destructive pest to an olive orchard. A crop can not be saved when the migration of the robin corresponds exactly with the maturity of the olive, as it does this year, except by immediate picking, which is practically impossible, or by shooting so constantly as to prevent steady consumption….
In 1898 my crop was 130 tons, and should have made about 4,000 gallons of oil. Owing to the lack of rain the result was about 2,750 gallons, of the value of $11,000. Now, that crop could have been wiped out in 10 days by robins if they had been here as they were this season and no shooting had been done.
So far as my foreman could estimate, before the birds descended upon the place, he placed the crop at a probable 3,000 gallons, which means when sold from $12,000 to $16,000, according to prices, and that would have been utterly destroyed but for the constant shooting the last 10 days.
Get our free Hummingbird Attraction Guide! Plus, we'll send you our best tips for attracting more birds to your yard.
As it was, Mr. Goodrich placed his loss on the olive crop through the devastations of the robins at 25 per cent of the whole, or about $5,000.
The San Jose Mercury also states: A representative of the Mercury visited the El Quito olive orchard to see what the facts were in this matter. He found a force of men picking the fruit as rapidly as possible, and he also saw thousands upon thousands of robins doing the same thing. On his way out he occasionally saw a single bird on the fence or in a prune tree, but when he reached El Quito the sky was streaked with robins flitting about and having a gala time of it.
Men were scattered about through the orchard with guns, and every few minutes the report of one of these would set the robins to flying, but in an instant they would settle down again and resume their feast.
Fifteen years of it, up and down the coast
Ellwood Cooper, of Santa Barbara, a prominent producer of olives on the Pacific coast, in a letter dated January 25, 1901, says: The robin is a terrible pest to olives. The birds do not always appear to come to the coast. My first experience was some 15 years ago. The olives were late in ripening.
I was as late as March making oil. The robins appeared to come in by the thousands. My last orchard that year was about one-half mile in length. The pickers were at one end. I had a man with a gun at the other, but they would attack the middle, and when the gunner would reach them they would fly to the end he left.
This year they have been particularly bad. My boys reported that the birds, mostly robins, picked more olives than they could. The foreman of the pickers told me that he had knocked from a tree one-quarter of a sack and went to dinner; when he returned not an olive was on the ground. I know that on the ground in one orchard where the rain had caused to fall as many olives as would fill a bushel basket, in a week not one would be seen.
The robins do not seem to be able to pick the olives so rapidly from the trees, but peck at those that are commencing to dry, knock them to the ground, then get them. The birds at this writing are in all my orchards by the thousands. They do not appear every year. It has been my theory that the native berries in the Sierra some years are not in sufficient quantities for food.
In the last sentence Mr. Cooper has probably struck the root of the trouble. There is a crop of olives every year and the number of robins fluctuates little.
| Witness or claim | Figure |
|---|---|
| Robins on one orchard, the owner’s estimate | 50,000 |
| Whole olives found in a single bird’s crop | five or six |
| Masson’s expected crop — and what was left | about 4 tons; “not worth picking” |
| Goodrich’s 1898 crop | 130 tons — about 2,750 gallons of oil, worth $11,000 |
| His expected 1900-01 crop | a probable 3,000 gallons — $12,000 to $16,000 |
| Yield ruined even in defended orchards | one-fourth to one-half |
The bureau’s verdict
Summary.—While the animal food of the robin includes a rather large percentage of useful beetles, it is not in the consumption of these or any other insect that this bird does harm. A bird whose diet contains so large a percentage of fruit, including so many varieties, may at any time become a pest when its natural food fails and cultivated varieties are accessible.
While the robin to-day probably is doing much more good than harm, it must be acknowledged that the bird is potentially harmful. In New Jersey it has been protected for years by law and also by public opinion, while the native berrybearing shrubs have been destroyed and their places filled by domestic varieties; consequently the birds have been obliged to resort to cultivated fruits for food, while fruit growers have seen the berry crop, their principal source of income, disappear.
It is not probable that individually fruit growers have derived benefit enough from the birds’ insectivorous habits to counterbalance the loss suffered through their agency. Briefly, the conditions are: Too many birds of a single species and too little of their natural food. Under such circumstances there is no doubt that a law allowing the fruit grower to protect his crop when attacked by birds would be proper.
In California conditions are somewhat similar though differing in detail. The canyons and hillsides normally supply robins with their winter food. This, however, sometimes fails, especially since the hill and canyon lands have been cleared to bring them under cultivation as orchards and farms. It is not surprising that robins accept olives as a fair substitute for the Madrona, Heteromeles, and Cascara berries taken from them.
Here again is found the very undesirable condition of too many birds of a single species collected in a limited area. They all demand the same kind of food, and when it fails the birds seek till they find an acceptable substitute. It is usually preferable to supply the food they desire, and for which they will amply pay, instead of killing the birds.
Briefly, the conditions are: Too many birds of a single species and too little of their natural food.
Source
F. E. L. Beal, Food of the Robins and Bluebirds of the United States, USDA Bulletin 171 (1915), vegetable food of the robin and summary, including growers’ statements quoted by the bulletin from the San Jose Mercury of January 17, 1901. Public domain. Biodiversity Heritage Library / Internet Archive.
Passages reproduced verbatim from the scanned original. Hard line-wraps joined and the scan’s doubled word spacing collapsed; page headers, plate captions and the sources’ reference footnotes omitted; footnote reference marks (superscript digits, asterisks and daggers printed after sentences) removed; OCR pipe characters removed; the printers’ space before punctuation closed up and compound hyphens the scan breaks apart closed. Single-glyph OCR corrections: “on the El] Quito farm” to “on the El Quito farm”; “winter bird and is-abundant” to “winter bird and is abundant”; “which is prac‘tically impossible” to “which is practically impossible”; “prevent steady consumption. * * * In 1898” to “prevent steady consumption. … In 1898”; “about one-half mile – in length” to “about one-half mile in length”; “which is owned by Hh. EK. Goodrich” to “which is owned by H. E. Goodrich”; “when I yisited my orchard” to “when I visited my orchard”; “A crop can nov be saved” to “A crop can not be saved”; “any part of the crop ean be saved” to “any part of the crop can be saved”; “told me that he bad knocked from a tree” to “told me that he had knocked from a tree”; “does harm. <A bird whose diet” to “does harm. A bird whose diet”; “a single species .and too little” to “a single species and too little”; “a law allowing the frwit grower” to “a law allowing the fruit grower”; “the animal food of the.robin” to “the animal food of the robin”; “substitute for the I/adrona, Heteromeles, and Cascara berries” to “substitute for the Madrona, Heteromeles, and Cascara berries”. Cuts, always at sentence boundaries: the run ends where the bulletin turns to its wild-fruit lists (its printed tables do not survive OCR and are not reproduced), so the final Cooper paragraph closes mid-discussion at ‘the number of robins fluctuates little’; the summary section is reproduced through the California paragraph and stops before the varied-thrush chapter. The wild-vs-cultivated opening lines (which also serve the companion robin guide) are quoted here only in the table caption.
📷 Show us your feeder setup! Share a few photos of your feeders and you might be featured on Wild Bird Scoop. Share your setup →








