If you’ve ever picked up a bottle of commercial hummingbird nectar, you’ve probably noticed the bright red color. It seems harmless—even helpful, since hummingbirds love red flowers. But that one ingredient, red dye, is something experts say you should never add to your feeders. The good news? You don’t need it, and making your own nectar is easier than you think.
The Hidden Problem With Commercial Hummingbird Nectar
Save this article for later so you don't lose it. Enter your email and I'll send it to you now—plus you'll get my favorite backyard birding tips delivered to your inbox.
Birdfy Solar Powered Bird House with Camera
Check PriceWalk down any birding aisle and you’ll find shelves stocked with brightly colored hummingbird nectar. The marketing suggests it’s what hummingbirds need, but wildlife organizations tell a different story. The National Audubon Society, along with other respected bird conservation groups, strongly recommends against using any nectar that contains red dye or other additives.
Here’s the truth: hummingbirds don’t need red nectar. They’re attracted to the color of your feeder, not what’s inside it. Most hummingbird feeders already have red components—red bases, red feeding ports, or red accents—and that’s more than enough to catch their attention. The red dye in commercial nectar serves only one purpose: to appeal to human shoppers who assume it’s necessary.
Beyond being unnecessary, these additives can potentially cause harm. While manufacturers argue that food-grade dyes are safe, the reality is that we don’t have long-term studies on how these chemicals affect hummingbirds specifically. Their tiny bodies, rapid metabolisms, and unique physiology mean they process substances very differently than humans do. Why take the risk when there’s a perfectly safe alternative?
Commercial nectars also tend to be expensive. You’re paying a premium for water, sugar, and unnecessary chemicals when you could make a better product at home for pennies per batch.
What Red Dye Does to Hummingbirds
The most common dye found in commercial hummingbird nectar is FD&C Red No. 40, a petroleum-based synthetic color additive. While it’s approved for human consumption in the United States, that doesn’t automatically make it safe for wildlife. In fact, Red No. 40 and similar dyes are banned or require warning labels in several European countries due to concerns about hyperactivity in children and potential links to other health issues.
When hummingbirds consume dyed nectar, those chemicals are absorbed into their bodies. Given that hummingbirds may visit feeders dozens of times per day and consume up to half their body weight in nectar, the cumulative exposure can be significant. Their livers and kidneys must process these foreign substances, placing additional stress on organs that are already working overtime to fuel their incredibly fast metabolisms.
The long-term effects remain largely unknown because comprehensive studies simply haven’t been done. We don’t know how red dye might affect their reproduction, migration stamina, or overall lifespan. Some wildlife rehabilitators have reported seeing kidney and liver damage in hummingbirds, though establishing a direct link to dyed nectar is challenging.
Get our free Hummingbird Attraction Guide! Plus, we'll send you our best tips for attracting more birds to your yard.
What we do know is this: hummingbirds have thrived for millions of years on flower nectar, which is naturally clear or slightly amber. There’s no evolutionary reason they would need or benefit from artificial coloring. The precautionary principle applies here—when in doubt, stick with what nature intended.
The Simple Solution: Make Your Own in Five Minutes
Making hummingbird nectar at home is remarkably easy, and you probably already have everything you need. The recipe recommended by the National Audubon Society and other wildlife organizations couldn’t be simpler: one part white granulated sugar to four parts water. That’s it.
Here’s how to do it:
- Bring water to a boil to help dissolve the sugar and kill any bacteria or mold spores
- Stir in white granulated sugar until completely dissolved (for example, 1 cup sugar to 4 cups water)
- Let the mixture cool completely before filling your feeders
- Store any extra nectar in the refrigerator for up to two weeks
A few important notes: always use plain white sugar—never honey, brown sugar, artificial sweeteners, or organic sugar. Honey can promote dangerous fungal growth. Brown sugar and organic sugar contain iron and molasses that hummingbirds don’t need. Artificial sweeteners provide no calories, which defeats the entire purpose since hummingbirds need the energy that sugar provides.
You also don’t need to add red dye. Your feeder’s red parts will do all the attracting. Once hummingbirds discover your feeder, they’ll return for the food quality, not the color.
The cost savings are substantial. A four-pound bag of sugar costs around three dollars and will make several gallons of nectar—enough to last most backyard birders an entire season. Compare that to spending eight to ten dollars for a single bottle of commercial nectar, and you’ll quickly see why making your own makes sense.
Keeping Your Feeders Safe: Maintenance and Storage Tips
Fresh, clean nectar is just the starting point. How you maintain your feeders directly impacts hummingbird health. Nectar can ferment quickly, especially in warm weather, and dirty feeders can harbor harmful mold and bacteria.
Change your nectar regularly, even if it’s not empty. In temperatures above 90°F, replace it every one to two days. In cooler weather (60-80°F), every three to four days is acceptable. If you notice the nectar looks cloudy, discard it immediately.
Clean feeders thoroughly each time you refill them. Use hot water and a bottle brush to scrub all surfaces, paying special attention to feeding ports where mold loves to grow. A solution of one part white vinegar to four parts water works well for stubborn residue. Rinse thoroughly before refilling—soap residue can be harmful.
For storage, keep your homemade nectar refrigerated in a clean, sealed container. Glass jars work perfectly. Properly stored nectar will stay fresh for up to two weeks, making it easy to prepare larger batches.
Consider placing feeders in partial shade when possible. This keeps nectar cooler and slows fermentation. If you notice ants or bees at your feeder, try an ant moat or move the feeder to a different location rather than adding any substances to the nectar itself.
With these simple practices, you’ll provide a safe, healthy food source that truly benefits the hummingbirds visiting your yard. They’ll thank you by returning season after season, bringing their incredible energy and beauty to your backyard. Happy birding!