For decades, backyard birders have been told to avoid red dye in hummingbird nectar. The warning has become gospel in birding circles, passed down with certainty and concern. But what does the science actually say, and what truly happens when hummingbirds consume dyed sugar water?
Where the Red Dye Myth Started
Save this article for later so you don't lose it. Enter your email and I'll send it to you now—plus you'll get my favorite backyard birding tips delivered to your inbox.
Birdfy Solar Powered Bird House with Camera
Check PriceThe concern about red dye traces back to the 1970s and 1980s, when commercial hummingbird nectars routinely included Red Dye #40 to make the liquid more visually appealing to humans. The logic seemed sound—hummingbirds are attracted to red flowers, so red nectar must be better, right?
Not quite. Hummingbirds don’t need red nectar. They’re drawn to red feeders and red flowers because those colors signal food sources in nature, but the liquid inside doesn’t need to be colored at all. The dye was purely a marketing decision.
Around the same time, concerns emerged about artificial food colorings and their potential health effects. When studies showed that some dyes could cause health problems in lab rats at very high doses, the birding community understandably grew worried. If red dye could harm mammals, what might it do to tiny birds with fast metabolisms?
The precautionary principle took hold. Better safe than sorry became the mantra, and birders began warning each other to skip the dye entirely. That advice spread through bird clubs, gardening groups, and eventually across the internet.
What Science Says About Red Dye #40
Here’s where things get nuanced. Red Dye #40, also called Allura Red AC, is one of the most studied food colorings in use today. It’s approved by the FDA for human consumption and appears in countless foods, drinks, and medications.
The studies that raised alarm bells involved feeding massive quantities of dye to laboratory animals—doses far beyond what any creature would encounter in normal circumstances. Some showed potential links to hyperactivity in sensitive children and tumors in rats, but these findings came with significant caveats about dosage and application.
What about hummingbirds specifically? This is the critical question, and the honest answer is: we don’t have extensive controlled studies. No major research institution has systematically tested Red Dye #40 on hummingbirds in laboratory settings with proper control groups and long-term monitoring.
Get our free Hummingbird Attraction Guide! Plus, we'll send you our best tips for attracting more birds to your yard.
What we do have is observational evidence from wildlife rehabilitators and avian veterinarians. According to hummingbird rehabilitation experts, they haven’t documented clear cases of harm directly attributable to red dye in properly mixed nectar. However—and this matters—they still recommend against it, primarily because it’s unnecessary and introduces a variable we don’t fully understand.
What Actually Happens Inside Hummingbirds
Hummingbirds have extraordinarily fast metabolisms. Their hearts beat up to 1,260 times per minute during flight, and they must consume roughly half their body weight in nectar daily just to survive. This means their tiny bodies process substances incredibly quickly.
Their kidneys and liver work overtime to filter what they consume. Any unnecessary additive—whether it’s red dye, artificial sweeteners, or other chemicals—puts additional strain on these vital organs. Even if the dye isn’t acutely toxic, why add extra work for a bird whose system is already operating at maximum capacity?
There’s also the issue of concentration. When you add dye to a feeder, you’re creating a situation where a hummingbird might consume that substance repeatedly, day after day, potentially for an entire season. The cumulative effect of regular exposure, even to small amounts, remains unknown.
Some birders have reported seeing hummingbirds with stained plumage around their beaks and throats after using red nectar. While this doesn’t necessarily indicate internal harm, it suggests the dye isn’t being fully metabolized and is instead being deposited externally—a sign that the bird’s body may be working to eliminate it.
The most compelling argument against red dye isn’t that we know it’s harmful—it’s that we don’t know it’s safe, and we don’t need to take the risk.
The Simple, Safe Way to Feed Hummingbirds
The good news? Making safe, attractive hummingbird nectar is incredibly simple. Mix one part white granulated sugar with four parts water. That’s it. No dye, no honey, no artificial sweeteners, no brown sugar.
Boil the water first to kill any mold or bacteria, then stir in the sugar until it dissolves completely. Let it cool before filling your feeder. You can make a big batch and store it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks.
Your feeder itself provides all the red attraction you need. Most hummingbird feeders feature red bases, red feeding ports, or red accents that catch the birds’ attention perfectly. If your feeder happens to be clear or another color, consider tying a red ribbon near it or positioning it near red flowers.
Keep your feeders clean—this matters far more than nectar color. Change the solution every three to five days in cool weather, and every two days when temperatures climb above 80 degrees. Mold and fermentation pose real, documented dangers to hummingbirds, unlike the theoretical risks of dye.
If you want to do more for your hummingbirds, plant native nectar flowers in red, orange, and pink: bee balm, cardinal flower, trumpet vine, salvia, and penstemon all provide natural food sources that support healthy birds and healthy ecosystems.
The bottom line is simple. Skip the red dye. It adds nothing beneficial and carries potential risks we can’t fully measure. Plain sugar water in a red feeder gives hummingbirds exactly what they need without any of the uncertainty. Your tiny visitors will thrive on the simplest recipe—and you’ll enjoy them with complete peace of mind.
Happy birding!